Myths & Facts

  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Learn More
  4. /
  5. Myths & Facts

MYTH: Old-growth logging is a thing of the past.

REALITY: Tens of thousands of hectares of ancient forests are logged each year in BC, resulting in a huge climate and environmental footprint. In the past 150 years on BC’s southern coast (Vancouver Island and the southwest mainland), 75% of the original, productive old-growth forests have already been logged, including over 90% of the valley bottoms where the largest trees grow.

Old-growth logging on Edinburgh Mt. near Port Renfrew in 2016

MYTH: BC’s ancient forests are not endangered. (Ministry of Forests website factsheet states, “Old-growth forests are not disappearing.”)

REALITY: In order to placate public fears about the loss of BC’s endangered old-growth forests, the BC government’s PR-spin typically over-inflates the amount of remaining old-growth forests by including hundreds of thousands of hectares of marginal, low productivity forests growing in bogs and at high elevations with smaller, stunted trees, lumped in with the productive old-growth forests, where the large trees grow (and where most logging takes place). It’s like including your Monopoly money with your real money and then claiming to be a millionaire, so why curtail spending? 3.3 million hectares of productive old-growth forests once stood on the southern coast, and today, 860,000 hectares remain, while only 260,000 hectares are protected in parks and Old-Growth Management Areas.

Low productivity bog forest Port Renfrew.

Low productivity bog forest Port Renfrew.

MYTH: Old-growth logging isn’t a problem as long as the trees are replanted.

REALITY: Replanting does not adequately replicate an old-growth forest ecosystem. Second-growth or replanted forests lack many of the important features of old-growth forests. The trees are all the same age, so there are few gaps in the canopy to let light through and allow a rich understory to grow. In old-growth forests, the multi-layered canopy of differently-aged trees allow sunlight through, creating a rich, luxuriant understory that provides food and habitat for many species. It would take a long time, at least 200 years, for replanted stands to regain important old-growth characteristics. However, since the rotations are about 55 years on Crown lands on BC’s coast and as low as 30 years on private lands, these second-growth stands will never regain these characteristics. Many species, such as the marbled murrelet and northern spotted owl can only survive in old-growth forests, and these species are being driven to extinction due to logging in their critical habitat.

Second growth forest on Vancouver Island.

Second-growth forest on Vancouver Island.

MYTH: To counteract climate change, we need to replace our old-growth forests with healthy, fast-growing young trees that quickly sequester carbon.

REALITY: There is a massive net release of carbon from logging and replacing our old-growth forests with second-growth tree plantations. Old-growth forests on BC’s coast store about twice the carbon per hectare as the ensuing second-growth tree plantations they are being replaced with. Logging them releases vast amounts of carbon that would take 200 years to re-sequester, and only if forests were allowed to grow that long (which they don’t under the 50 to 80 year rotation age on BC’s coast – see link). Contrary to the timber industry’s PR-spin, old-growth forests continue to sequester significant amounts of carbon even as they age:

BC’s official greenhouse gas emissions in 2013 were 64 megatons of carbon dioxide, whereas destructive logging practices were responsible for the average release of 49.5 megatons of carbon dioxide annually over a 10 year period (2003-2012 were not counted as part of official emissions – see Sierra Club study). Only a minor fraction, as low as 15%, of the carbon from logging BC’s old-growth forests ends up in solid wood products. Unfortunately, the vast majority of it ends up relatively quickly into the atmosphere within a few years – see report.

A burnt-over old-growth clearcut in the Klanawa Valley on Vancouver Island.

A burnt-over old-growth clearcut in the Klanawa Valley on Vancouver Island.

MYTH: Old-growth logging is necessary to sustain the forest industry.

REALITY: The vast majority of forested lands in southern BC are now second-growth, including about 80% of the productive forest lands on BC’s southern coast. A full transition into logging only second-growth forests is inevitable when the last of the unprotected old-growth forests are logged out. For the sake of future generations, we need to make the transition into a second-growth, value-added forest industry soon BEFORE we eliminate the remaining unprotected old-growth forests. By logging second-growth stands at a slower, more sustainable rate of cut, and manufacturing more wood products here in BC – rather than increasing the export of raw logs to foreign mills – we can protect old-growth forests and sustain and create forestry jobs at the same time.

Second-growth logs near Sooke, BC.

Second-growth logs near Sooke, BC.

MYTH: Job losses in forestry are largely due to areas being set aside for conservation.

REALITY: BC’s forest industry was historically built on logging the biggest and best old-growth stands in the valley bottoms and lower slopes. Over time, the remaining trees have become smaller in size, lower in value and more expensive to reach on steep slopes at high elevations, far away in valley headwaters. Today on Vancouver Island, over 90% of the productive, valley-bottom old-growth forests that historically built the forest industry have now been logged. This has resulted in diminishing returns for the forest industry as expenses have gone up and revenues have declined, resulting in the closure of old-growth dependent sawmills everywhere and the loss of thousands of forestry jobs. In the mid 1990’s, almost 100,000 people were directly employed in BC’s forest industry; today, about 60,000 remain. The forest industry has boxed themselves into a corner through their own unsustainable history of overcutting the biggest and best old-growth stands and saying it’s conservationists’ fault. They think in order to survive, they must log the last unprotected lowland ancient forests.

Around the world – whether one looks at fishing down the food chain or old-growth logging – this pattern of high-grade resource depletion of taking too much, too fast of the biggest and best, has resulted in the collapse of both ecosystems and of resource-dependent communities. Not only do we lose the biodiversity – and water quality in this case – we lose the jobs.

The decline in forestry employment has particularly been exacerbated when the BC Liberal government largely deregulated the forest industry, removing the local milling requirement in 2003 that – had it remained – would have mandated logging companies convert their old-growth mills to handle the maturing second-growth stands. Instead, as the original mills shut down, there has been a mass exodus of raw, unprocessed logs leaving the province for foreign mills, facilitated by the BC Liberals, which marketed our logs and last old-growth stands in China.

Giant cedar stump. Klanawa Valley - Vancouver Island, BC.

Giant cedar stump. Klanawa Valley – Vancouver Island, BC.

Raw logs awaiting export on a ship in Nanaimo, BC.

Raw logs awaiting export on a ship in Nanaimo, BC.

Let's make the world a better place

Working to protect BC’s endangered old-growth forests and ensure a sustainable, second-growth forest industry.