Ancient Forest Alliance
FIND A PAGEFIND A PAGE
  • Home
  • About Us
        • The six AFA team members stand beside each other in front of an old-growth Douglas-fir tree.
        • Our Mission & Team
        • History & Successes
        • Work With Us
        • Contact Us
  • Our Work
    • Campaigns
    • Building Alliances
    • Activity Reports
  • Ancient Forests
    • Hiking Guides
    • Old-Growth 101
    • Old-Growth Forests in BC: FAQs
    • Before & After Old-Growth Maps
    • Myths & Facts
    • Directions to Avatar Grove
    • Port Renfrew Big Trees Map
  • Recent News
    • Recent News
    • Media Releases
    • Research & Reports
    • Publications
    • Educational
  • Photos & Media
        • Map of Gallery Locations
        • Themes
          • Biggest Trees
          • Biggest Stumps
          • Low Productivity Old-Growth
        • Videos
        • Vancouver Island North
          • East Creek Rainforest
          • Klaskish Inlet
          • Quatsino
            • Grove of Giant Cedars Clearcut in Quatsino Sound
            • Quatsino Old-Growth Under Threat 2023
            • Mahatta River Logging
          • Spruce Bay
          • Tsitika Valley
          • White River Provincial Park
        • Vancouver Island Central
          • Barkley Sound
            • Vernon Bay
          • Clayoquot Sound
            • Canada’s Most Impressive Tree – Flores Island
            • Flores Island
            • Meares Island
            • Sydney River Valley
          • Cortes Island
            • Children’s Forest
            • Squirrel Cove Ancient Forest
          • Nootka Island
          • Port Alberni
            • Cameron Valley Firebreak
            • Cathedral Grove Canyon
            • Juniper Ridge
            • Katlum Creek
            • Nahmint Valley
            • Nahmint Logging 2024
            • McLaughlin Ridge
            • Mount Horne
            • Taylor River Valley
          • Tahsis
            • McKelvie Valley
            • Tahsis: Endangered Old-Growth Above Town
        • Vancouver Island South
          • Carmanah
            • Climbing the Largest Spruce in Carmanah
            • Carmanah Research Climb
          • Caycuse Watershed
            • Before & After Logging – Caycuse Watershed
            • Before and After Logging Caycuse 2022
            • Caycuse Logging From Above
            • Lower Caycuse River
            • Massive Trees Cut Down
          • Klanawa Valley
          • Koksilah
          • Mossy Maples
            • Mossy Maple Gallery
            • Mossy Maple Grove
          • Port Renfrew
            • Avatar Boardwalk
            • Avatar Grove
            • Big Lonely Doug and Clearcut
            • Bugaboo Ridge Ancient Forest
            • Eden Grove
            • Exploring & Climbing Ancient Giants
            • Fairy Creek Headwaters
            • Granite Creek Logging
            • Jurassic Grove
            • Loup Creek
            • Mossome Grove
            • Mossome Grove Tree Climb
          • Walbran Valley
            • Castle Grove
            • Central Walbran Ancient Forest
            • Hadikin Lake
            • Walbran Headwaters At Risk
            • Walbran Overview
            • Walbran Logging
        • Haida Gwaii
        • Sunshine Coast
          • Day Road Forest
          • Mt. Elphinstone Proposed Park Expansion
          • Powell River
            • Eldred River Valley
            • Mt. Freda Ancient Forests
          • Roberts Creek Headwaters
          • Stillwater Bluffs
        • Inland Rainforest
          • Ancient Forest/ Chun T’oh Whudujut Provincial Park
          • Parthenon Grove
        • Mainland
          • Echo Lake
          • Kanaka Bar IPCA Proposal
  • Take Action
    • Send A Message to the BC Government
    • Sign Petition
    • Sign a Resolution
  • Store
  • Donate
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu
  • Store
  • Donate
News Coverage
Mar 4 2013

Rollover Legislation: Claims and Facts

Mar 4 2013/News Coverage

The government and the Minister of Forests continue to spread disinformation about the forestry rollover legislation that was introduced this month. You can read the proposed law for yourself here, in Section 24.

During a February 28th interview, Minister Thomson made the following claims:

“Clearly in that legislation we’ve talked about the process. We’ve talked about the need for public consultation that’s embedded in the legislation. We’ve talked about that this would only occur when it is in the public interest. It would be by invitation, so it’s not a de facto privatization. And it responds to the recommendations of the mid-term timber supply committee report that have clearly said we need to look at increasing the diversity of area-based management. There are significant benefits to area-based management in terms of investments in forest management, increasing fibre supply, and we think this is one of the tools that will assist in addressing the mid-term timber supply needs.”

I’ve responded to the government and minister’s statements below.

1. Claim: This legislation comes as a direct result of a recommendation by the Special Committee on Timber Supply.

Fact: There was no such recommendation. The Timber Supply Committee gave cautionary recommendations “if conversion to more area-based tenures is desirable.”[1]

2. Claim: This legislation is about increasing the diversity of area-based tenures, like community forests, woodlots and First Nations tenures.

Fact: It’s about conversion of one specific type of volume-based license, called a replaceable forest license, to a specific type of area-based tenure, a Tree Farm License (TFL). The majority of the volume held under these licenses is in the control of five major forest products companies.

The government already has the ability to create more community forests, First Nations area-based tenures, and woodlots. It still hasn’t met its stated 2003 objective of having these types of tenures comprise 10 per cent of the province-wide annual allowable cut.

3. Claim: Area-based tenures result in better forest management.

Fact: Area-based tenures may result in better forest management, but it’s not necessarily the case, because area-based tenure holders only have to meet the minimum requirements of the Forest Act. There are no legal requirements for companies to manage their forests to a higher standard.

There has not been a definitive assessment of whether the public forest land base is actually better managed under a TFL. In fact, the worst managed public forest in BC has historically been TFL #1, on the north coast.

4. Claim: Area-based tenures will increase mid-term timber supply.

Fact: There is no evidence to support this claim. Some TFLs have improved their silviculture investments enough to warrant an increase in their AAC. However, many TFLs have seen their AACs reduced, and those that are able to demonstrate an improvement in timber volume get to cut that volume today based on their projected results for future improvements in forest growth. These projections do not account for climate change, fire, pests, and disease, which could wipe out any incremental gains.

5. Claim: There will be public consultation.

Fact: There is no public consultation required by law at any point in the rollover process. The only requirement is to make an accepted proposal “available” for public comment for a period of not less than 60 days. This is a passive process that does not compel the applicant to actively notify and engage First Nations, local governments, other licensees, and community stakeholders.

6. Claim: First Nations will be consulted.

Fact: The maps for new TFLs will be drawn by the applicants and negotiated in secret with the Minister. There is no legal requirement for direct pre- or post-consultation with First Nations. This omission will likely trigger “duty to consult” litigation against both the legislation and any applications made under the legislation

7. Claim: The public interest will be protected.

Fact: There is no “public interest” definition in the legislation. No requirements for investment, job creation, mills to be built, or incremental forest management. The government press release promises the public will be consulted this summer before the legislation is used in order to “refine” the policy around public interest. However, as the Auditor General’s report on the release of private lands from existing TFLs clearly points out, the government did not protect the public interest in that case, and public interest policy can be adapted without any public consultation.

8. Claim: This legislation simply enables the minister to invite replaceable license holders to apply for an area-based tenure. There is no government policy to rollover replaceable forest licenses to TFLs.

Fact: This same rationalization was used when the government changed the Forest Act to allow the removal of private lands from TFLs. After the first application to remove private lands form a TFL was approved, successive applications resulted in the removal of virtually all of the private lands in TFLs province-wide. The Auditor General’s report on private land removals concluded that the public interest was not protected in this process.

9. Claim: The invitation to apply will be publicly advertised according to a prescribed process and will lay out the criteria for a successful application.

Fact: The prescribed process and criteria are not in law. In most TSAs, only one or two major companies hold most of the available volume in their replaceable forest licenses, and only they would be eligible to submit a proposal in the first place.

10. Claim: This legislation is not “privatization” of our public forests.

Fact: TFLs give exclusive rights to private companies over a defined area (or areas) of our public forest land. Once awarded, the minister has virtually no oversight or input into the sale of TFLs, and there are no public consultation requirements or First Nation consultation requirements when TFLs change hands. Foreign state-owned entities are able to buy TFLs without notice to the public or any public input. In fact, a Chinese business person who purchased TFL #1 is under scrutiny in China for defrauding the Chinese government when he purchased Skeena Cellulose and the licenses associated with that mill.

TFLs are no longer taken back if processing facilities are sold, and they can be managed to minimum standards without penalty. TFL #47 formerly fed mills in the Campbell River area, but those mills are closed. The TFL is now primarily logged for log exports, and the TFL is owned by a pension fund.

If government wants to take back areas of a TFL in order to protect other values, create parks, settle land claims, or attract investment for other timber or non-timber economic activity, compensation to TFL holders is significantly higher because of the exclusive territorial rights awarded to the license holder. In short, we have to buy back our public forests from TFL licensees, just as if we were purchasing private land.

11. Claim: This legislation is about mid-term timber supply and community stability.

Fact: This legislation is about Burns Lake and Hampton Affiliates. Hampton Affiliates is an Oregon-based company that was a member of the Coalition for Fair Lumber Imports in the US, which received money from the $1 billion the US Government took from Canadian companies when the Harper government signed the 2006 Softwood Lumber Agreement.[2] Hampton is potentially facing charges under the Workers’ Compensation Act for the events leading up to the explosion of the Babine Forest Products Mill. The government started promising Hampton Affiliates a TFL as early as April 2012, long before the Timber Supply Committee was struck.

The Minister promised to introduce this legislation for Hampton in a letter of intent he wrote to the company in September 2012:

“We will bring legislation to the House at the next session. Conversion of Babine Forest Products licenses will be one of the first priorities for implementation under any resultant legislation. Babine has submitted a proposal for an area based tenure in historic Babine operating areas and we would expect a portion or portions of this area to be included in the area based licence that would be offered to Babine. The total area that would be offered will be commensurate with the proportion of cut held by Hampton.”

This legislation was created for the wrong reasons, without proper consultation, and the law itself does not provide the protections the government and minister say it does. There are only two weeks in which the law could be debated and passed. If it comes before the House again, I will stand up and fight this bill.

Please also see Bob’s media release on this subject.
Read More: https://www.bobsimpsonmla.ca/rollover-legislation-claims-and-facts/

Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on X
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Myths_vs_Facts.png 219 300 TJ Watt https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/cropped-AFA-Logo-1000px.png TJ Watt2013-03-04 00:00:002023-04-06 19:08:50Rollover Legislation: Claims and Facts
Search Search

Recent News

  • Photo: Cute Bear Cub Climbs Tree!Jul 11 2025
  • Thank you to these businesses and organizations!Jul 9 2025
  • My Comox Valley Now: Commercial logging isn’t happening in BC parks; says BC MinisterJul 4 2025
View All Posts

Categories

Archive

Find us on

  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to Youtube
  • Link to TikTok
  • Link to Bluesky
  • Link to Reddit

Take Action Template

Take action by sending an instant message to protect old-growth forests!

Related Posts

My Comox Valley Now: Commercial logging isn’t happening in BC parks; says BC Minister

Jul 4 2025
In a letter to the Ancient Forest Alliance and Endangered Ecosystems Alliance, Minister of Environment and Parks Tamara Davidson confirmed that there’s no commercial logging happening in provincial parks and it isn’t permitted under the BC Parks Act. The letter comes following reports of potential commercial salvage logging and fuel load reduction projects happening in these parks.
Read more
News Coverage
https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/2-Old-Growth-Douglas-Fir-Kentucky-Alleyne-Park.jpg 1467 2200 TJ Watt https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/cropped-AFA-Logo-1000px.png TJ Watt2025-07-04 16:18:482025-07-04 16:55:54My Comox Valley Now: Commercial logging isn’t happening in BC parks; says BC Minister

My Cowichan Valley Now: Conservationists call for BC forestry industry to be modernized

Mar 24 2025
Conservationists call for BC’s forestry industry to be modernized amid ongoing US tariff threats.
Read more
News Coverage
https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/3-Eden-Grove-Ken-Wu-1536x1024-1.jpg 1024 1536 TJ Watt https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/cropped-AFA-Logo-1000px.png TJ Watt2025-03-24 16:23:282025-03-24 16:24:21My Cowichan Valley Now: Conservationists call for BC forestry industry to be modernized

Toronto Star: The best place to go forest bathing? The ancient groves of Vancouver Island offer a meditative journey back in time

Mar 21 2025
British Columbia is home to some of the most enormous trees on the planet. Credit for the rise of tall-tree tourism here goes to the Ancient Forest Alliance, a charitable organization that advocates for protecting B.C.’s endangered old-growth forests.
Read more
News Coverage
https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/1-Avatar-Grove-Tourists-1.jpg 1200 1800 TJ Watt https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/cropped-AFA-Logo-1000px.png TJ Watt2025-03-21 11:20:502025-03-21 11:27:17Toronto Star: The best place to go forest bathing? The ancient groves of Vancouver Island offer a meditative journey back in time
Two people stand on a rock by the Fraser River in Kanaka Bar territory.

VIDEO: Inside Kanaka Bar’s Conservation Plan: Protecting Rare Ecosystems & Indigenous Culture

Feb 21 2025
We're excited to share an amazing new video with you featuring the Kanaka Bar Indian Band's proposed T’eqt’aqtn Indigenous Protected and Conserved Area (IPCA).
Read more
News Coverage
https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/Inside-Kanaka-Bar-Video-Thumbnail-scaled.jpg 1440 2560 TJ Watt https://ancientforestalliance.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/cropped-AFA-Logo-1000px.png TJ Watt2025-02-21 14:04:192025-02-28 17:05:19VIDEO: Inside Kanaka Bar’s Conservation Plan: Protecting Rare Ecosystems & Indigenous Culture
See All Posts

Take Action

 Donate

Support the Ancient Forest Alliance with a one-time or monthly donation.
How to Give

 Send a Message

Send an instant message to key provincial decision-makers.
Take Action

Get in Touch

Phone

(250) 896-4007 (Mon-Fri 9am-5pm)

Address

205-620 View Street
Victoria, B.C. V8W 1J6

Privacy Policy

  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to Youtube
  • Link to TikTok
  • Link to Bluesky
  • Link to Reddit

Resources

  • Recent News
  • Old Growth FAQs
  • Research & Reports
  • Photos & Media
  • Videos
  • Hiking Guides
  • Old-Growth 101

Who We Are

  • Our Mission & Team
  • History & Successes
  • Activity Reports
  • Contact
Ancient Forest Alliance

The Ancient Forest Alliance (AFA) is a registered charitable organization working to protect BC’s endangered old-growth forests and to ensure a sustainable, value-added, second-growth forest industry.

AFA’s office is located on the territories of the Lekwungen Peoples, also known as the Songhees and Esquimalt Nations.
Copyright © 2025 Ancient Forest Alliance • All Rights Reserved
Earth-Friendly Web Design by Fairwind Creative
Scroll to top
Ancient Forest AllianceLogo Header Menu
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Mission & Team
    • History & Successes
    • Work With Us
    • Contact Us
  • Our Work
    • Our Work
    • Activity Reports
    • Building Alliances
    • Campaigns
  • Ancient Forests
    • Hiking Guides
    • Old-Growth 101
    • Old-Growth Forests in BC: FAQs
    • Before & After Old-Growth Maps
    • Myths & Facts
    • Directions to Avatar Grove
    • Port Renfrew Big Trees Map
  • Recent News
    • Recent News
    • Research & Reports
    • Media Releases
    • Publications
    • Educational
  • Photos & Media
    • Map of Gallery Regions
    • Themes
      • Biggest Trees
      • Biggest Stumps
      • Low Productivity Old-Growth
    • Videos
    • Inland Rainforest
      • Ancient Forest/ Chun T’oh Whudujut Provincial Park
      • Parthenon Grove
    • Mainland
      • Echo Lake
      • Kanaka Bar IPCA Proposal
    • Haida Gwaii
    • Sunshine Coast
      • Day Road Forest
      • Mt. Elphinstone Proposed Park Expansion
      • Roberts Creek Headwaters
      • Stillwater Bluffs
    • Sunshine Coast: Powell River
      • Eldred River Valley
      • Mt. Freda Ancient Forests
    • Vancouver Island South
      • Climbing the Largest Spruce in Carmanah
      • Carmanah Research Climb
      • Klanawa Valley
      • Koksilah
    • VI South: Caycuse Watershed
      • Before & After Logging – Caycuse Watershed
      • Before and After Logging Caycuse 2022
      • Caycuse Logging From Above
      • Lower Caycuse River
      • Massive Trees Cut Down
    • VI South: Mossy Maples
      • Mossy Maple Gallery
      • Mossy Maple Grove
    • VI South: Port Renfrew
      • Avatar Boardwalk
      • Avatar Grove
      • Big Lonely Doug and Clearcut
      • Bugaboo Ridge Ancient Forest
      • Eden Grove
      • Exploring & Climbing Ancient Giants
      • Fairy Creek Headwaters
      • Granite Creek Logging
      • Jurassic Grove
      • Loup Creek
      • Mossome Grove
      • Mossome Grove Tree Climb
    • VI South: Port Alberni
      • Cameron Valley Firebreak
      • Cathedral Grove Canyon
      • Juniper Ridge
      • Katlum Creek
      • Nahmint Valley
      • Nahmint Logging 2024
      • McLaughlin Ridge
      • Mount Horne
      • Taylor River Valley
    • VI South: Walbran Valley
      • Castle Grove
      • Central Walbran Ancient Forest
      • Hadikin Lake
      • Walbran Headwaters At Risk
      • Walbran Overview
      • Walbran Logging
    • Vancouver Island Central
      • Barkley Sound: Vernon Bay
      • Nootka Island
    • VI Central: Clayoquot Sound
      • Canada’s Most Impressive Tree – Flores Island
      • Flores Island
      • Meares Island
      • Sydney River Valley
    • VI Central: Cortes Island
      • Children’s Forest
      • Squirrel Cove Ancient Forest
    • VI Central: Tahsis
      • McKelvie Valley
      • Tahsis: Endangered Old-Growth Above Town
    • Vancouver Island North
      • East Creek Rainforest
      • Klaskish Inlet
      • Mahatta River Logging
      • Quatsino
      • Spruce Bay
      • Tsitika Valley
      • White River Provincial Park
  • Take Action
    • Send a Message
    • Sign Petition
    • Sign a Resolution
  • Store
  • Donate